Name your TOP 10 favourite games of all time

Ned Edgewalker

Wanted Pirate
Just thought it would be interesting to see everyone's favorite 10 games! So, why not?

No specific genre or anything, just list your top 10 games of all-time!


  1. Super Mario 64 (1996)
  2. Pirates of the Caribbean Online (2007-2013)
  3. WWE Smackdown vs. Raw 2008 (2007)
  4. Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood (2010)
  5. Roller Coaster Tycoon 2 (2002)
  6. Metal Gear Solid (1998)
  7. Crash Bash (2001)
  8. Grand Theft Auto IV (2007)
  9. NHL 11 (2011)
  10. The Wolf Among Us (2013)

2017 update:
  1. Super Mario 64 (1996)
  2. Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood (2010)
  3. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain (2015)
  4. Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door (2004)
  5. The Walking Dead (2012)
  6. Red Dead Redemption (2010)
  7. Dragon Age: Inquisition (2014)
  8. Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater (2004)
  9. WWE Smackdown! vs. Raw 2008 (2007)
  10. Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag (2013)
Honourable Mentions:
  • Assassin's Creed II (2009)
  • Assassin's Creed: Revelations (2011)
  • Grand Theft Auto IV (2008)
  • Pirates of the Caribbean Online (2007-2013)
  • Star Wars: Battlefront II (2005)
  • Super Mario Galaxy (2007)
  • Mario Tennis (2000)
  • Roller Coaster Tycoon 2 (2002)
 
Last edited:

Bobby Flat Foot

Pirate Lord
Hmm...

1. POTCO
2. Toontown
3. Wizard101
4. Crash Team Racing
5. Crash Bash
6. Crash Tag Team Racing
7. [Insert the many beloved but forgotten PS1/2 games]
8. Cake Mania 2
9. League of Legends
10. Roller Coaster Tycoon 1/2

Honorable Mention: Club Penguin

Quite a random assortment, I know. Crash Bandicoot dominated my early childhood, it being the first game series I ever remember playing. Then around my pre-teen years I discovered the internet and all the great games that lived there. I was turned on to Disney's MMOs by the commercials that I would constantly see while watching TV. I have not to this day found an MMO that could match the play style and great community that was offered by POTCO & Toontown (That being before the games entered their downfall).
 

Ned Edgewalker

Wanted Pirate
Hmm...

1. POTCO
2. Toontown
3. Wizard101
4. Crash Team Racing
5. Crash Bash
6. Crash Tag Team Racing
7. [Insert the many beloved but forgotten PS1/2 games]
8. Cake Mania 2
9. League of Legends
10. Roller Coaster Tycoon 1/2

Honorable Mention: Club Penguin

Quite a random assortment, I know. Crash Bandicoot dominated my early childhood, it being the first game series I ever remember playing. Then around my pre-teen years I discovered the internet and all the great games that lived there. I was turned on to Disney's MMOs by the commercials that I would constantly see while watching TV. I have not to this day found an MMO that could match the play style and great community that was offered by POTCO & Toontown (That being before the games entered their downfall).
Nice. :3
 

Solomon Warshot

Site Founder
Hmm...

1. POTCO
2. Toontown
3. Wizard101
4. Crash Team Racing
5. Crash Bash
6. Crash Tag Team Racing
7. [Insert the many beloved but forgotten PS1/2 games]
8. Cake Mania 2
9. League of Legends
10. Roller Coaster Tycoon 1/2

Honorable Mention: Club Penguin

Quite a random assortment, I know. Crash Bandicoot dominated my early childhood, it being the first game series I ever remember playing. Then around my pre-teen years I discovered the internet and all the great games that lived there. I was turned on to Disney's MMOs by the commercials that I would constantly see while watching TV. I have not to this day found an MMO that could match the play style and great community that was offered by POTCO & Toontown (That being before the games entered their downfall).
high-five for Crash: CTR. Could never get into Crash Bash but I loved CTR with a passion.
 
1. POTCO
2. Minecraft
3. TTR
4. TTO
5. Wizard101
6. Pirate101
7. Battlefield 4
8. Jurassic Park Operation Genesis PS2 ( not a common game )
9. Spore
10. Fossil Fighters

Honorable mentions : Lego Universe, Free Realms, WARFACE, Kingdom Rush 1-3
 

Kelly O'Kidd

Wanted Pirate
1. POTCO
2. LOTRO

Those are the only 2 MMO's I've ever played. And Lotro I've barely played, I think my character is a level 6 in that game. Which is why I'm desperate to see a POTCO remake come about soon. :)
I forgot, I had tried Pirates 101, I didn't like the combat system, it was weird to watch the characters fight each other instead of being more hands on with combat.
 
Last edited:

Kris

Pirate Lord
No particular order

1. POTCO
2. Grand Theft Auto Vice City/V
3. Age of Empires II
4. James Bond Goldeneye
5. Mario N64
6. Need for speed
7. wwe/wwf wrestling games
8. ncaa football 13
9. super mario
10. mario kart
 

PirateRaider

Swashbuckler
1 Runescape

2 Potco
3 Toontown
4 College hoops 2k8
5 medal of honor 2010
6 SWGemu
7 Any Nba 2k
8 Star wars battlefront 1 & 2
9 GTA SA,IV and V
10 Skyrim

theres many more games I love though
 

Sparky Wonderwolf

Site Founder
  1. POTCO
  2. Star Wars Battlefront II
  3. NationStates.net
  4. Minecraft
  5. Civilization V
  6. Injustice: Gods Among Us
  7. Sim City 4
  8. League Of Legends
  9. Madden (NFL)
  10. Star Trek Legacy
  11. Honorable Mentions:
  • League Of Legends
  • Skyrim (Only because I have not yet played it ;D)
  • Millsberry (I'm old school like that)
  • BioShock Infinite
 

Talaith

Honorable Pirate
In order... (POTCO was ranked 2nd before it closed, currently SHK is 2nd though)
1. LOTRO (Lord of the Rings Online) <---- has been my favorite since it went f2p, probably one of if not the only thing I preferred over POTCO back when it was out... (I am obsessed with Lord of the Rings. If you don't trust me, quiz me :p)
2. Stronghold Kingdoms
3. POTCO
4. Neverwinter
5. SWTOR (Star Wars the Old Republic)
6. All the original stronghold games! Except 3...
7. Dragon Age Origins
8. Star Wars Battlefront II
9. PotBS (Pirates of the Burning Seas)
10. The original Neverwinter Nights, if anyone remembers that :p
 

Chasemand1

Pirate Apprentice
1. CS:GO
2. Dota 2
3. Minecraft
4. Unturned
5. Call of Duty: Black Ops 2
6. ^^ And Black Ops 1
7. GTA V
8. NBA 2K (Any of em)
9. Madden NFL (16-17)
10. Battlefield 1
These are in no particular order.
 

Limitless1212

Pirate Apprentice
1. League Of Legends (DIAMOND BABY)
2. TLOPO
3. Minecraft
4. Mount and Blade: Warband
5. Dungeon Siege: Legends Of Arianna
6. Forged Alliance Forever (Supreme Commander: RTS game)
7. Skyrim
8.LOTRO
9.Tempest (steam game PLZ check it out... Stupid fun)
10. Magicka 1,2, and everything to do with Magicka....
 

Divine

Pirate Lord
  1. CS:GO
  2. TF2
  3. Wizard101
  4. APB Reloaded
  5. POTCO
  6. Assassins Creed Series
  7. Far Cry Series
  8. War Thunder
  9. Hitman Series
  10. Call Of Duty Franchise
 

Davy McShot

Pirate Master
1. GTA V (It's the first GTA I've ever played and I loved it. Level 200 on X360, some lower level on PS4 & X-One)
2. Toontown/TTR (Only really because the game was made well and it was my childhood tbh)
3. Minecraft (I own 4-5 servers for this game depending on how you look at it, we haven't had a strong playerbase in a while though :( )
4. POTCO/TLOPO
5. ARK: Survival Evolved (I love every aspect of this game other than nobody to play it with)
6. CS:GO (I've been banned twice though -- Update VAC!)
7. Wizard101 (My childhood after playing POTCO pretty much)
8. Pirate101 (Played this when it came out; gets a lot of hate; game isn't the best but it gets much better once you're through a lot of it)(A LOT)
9. Call of Duty: Black Ops II (I played this with school friends a lot on Xbox 360 -- before I moved schools :( ) Queue: The Sound of Silence
10. FATE: The Cursed King(I hope this is the right one. It came on my PC I played all this on when I was younger & I loved it idk y)

Please hmu/lmk if you have any of these games I would really love to play with you guys <3
 
Top