Items for Lucinda: Empty Rum Bottles Bug

[EggSensei]

The quest states that there is a shelf in Fort Charles with rum bottles in it.
https://gyazo.com/caffd6e33268530f09f73b6a4ee26b11
I am positive that this is the correct shelf, but it doesn't give any quest items.
https://gyazo.com/45db148c393d0f51f9d07217ba9e87e7

 

[SimTabouretski]

I am having the same problem. I am stuck!

 

[Lume]

Most search and recover items seemingly haven't been added or don't work currently.