If I had any surviving screenshots I'd probably be able to explain better, but; After a while I only had one outfit I'd wear constantly and it was all black (Not like Brights, just like the off-colour that you could buy). My pirate had no tattoos and maybe some ear piercings. It was really basic back then.
Plus I didn't really have time to customize my Pirate much since I sold my soul to farming for Brights.