Alli Honorable Pirate Dec 16, 2016 #121 We always leave peppermint cookies for Santa (just sugar cookies with peppermint on top)
Punkin Pie Pirate Lord Dec 16, 2016 #122 Well Santa seems to like Chocolate Chips and Cut-Out cookies the most, and we must leave an icy glass of milk for him! and be careful where you leave it!
Well Santa seems to like Chocolate Chips and Cut-Out cookies the most, and we must leave an icy glass of milk for him! and be careful where you leave it!
BullWhip Griffin Wanted Pirate Dec 16, 2016 #123 Pretty sure we put out chocolate chip and some other cookie
Captain Star Fantabulous Administrator Admin Dec 17, 2016 #124 Ahoy Everyone! Just a friendly reminder that this thread will be closing tomorrow. Hope you are enjoying the medals so far
Ahoy Everyone! Just a friendly reminder that this thread will be closing tomorrow. Hope you are enjoying the medals so far
Roger_ Gunshot Pirate Master Dec 17, 2016 #125 I think we left sugar cookies and chocolate chip...Now I'm hungry...
Smilin_Desperado Swashbuckler Dec 17, 2016 #126 Polvorones, Mexican Shortbread Cookies for Santa. I hope he likes Hispanic food
Mooseflies Swashbuckler Dec 17, 2016 #127 The baby carrot thing is the cutest thing ive ever heard. *clubs seal to feel manly again*
John Yellowrat Notorious Pirate Dec 17, 2016 #128 I think we usually leave Santa chocolate chip cookies - he never finishes them so I guess he doesn't like them too much :/
I think we usually leave Santa chocolate chip cookies - he never finishes them so I guess he doesn't like them too much :/
Mark Pondsmythe Swashbuckler Dec 17, 2016 #129 I usually leave the normal M&M or simple chocolate chip cookies, cut out in various Christmas themed shapes, such as a ginger bread man or a santa hat.
I usually leave the normal M&M or simple chocolate chip cookies, cut out in various Christmas themed shapes, such as a ginger bread man or a santa hat.
Captain Star Fantabulous Administrator Admin Dec 18, 2016 #131 Ahoy Everyone!! Three hours until we celebrate the Third Sunday!!