Ok, I'm old school Star Wars here. I've seen the Clone Wars movie, lol kids have it and some of the CW games, and I've seen most of the series on TV (until we got rid of cable). So, I dont know everyone you are talking about now. Of course, some of the old school SW fans do not like the CW (has to do with the fact that its a cartoon). *shrug*
Anyhoo... trying to mix something from one century to another is way off. Pirates took place in the Age of Piracy and Star Wars takes place so many millenia from now. You cannot compare the two other than as
El Corsario said above. Trying to merge the two would not work either. Lol can you imagine how much crazier Jack Sparrow would become once he saw some of the species from SW?!
Seriously, I think the only Sci-Fi story line that could possibly be merged with Pirates of the Caribbean would be Star Trek! Lol they already time traveled once...
I say no. It would be a bad idea and ruin Star Wars and Pirates as we know it.