the first one was awesome but it gets really stupid if u watch it over and over again lol
the second one was really good because it had everything in it but not really barbossa (i think hes the best charcater lol)
the third one... well you have to watch it like a thousand times to finaly figure out what is going on (then its really good!)
the last one ive only seen one time so.. its good but its missing THE BLACK PEARL AND THE MONKEY lol and the real barbossa
i like them all but the first and third are the best