Alright so this may or may not be a long list but here's some things that I believe are needed or would be helpful:
1. Gonna have to go with fix these major bugs most have been fixed then broken again in future updates. Bugs are such a pain in many factors and I really think these need to be top priority.
2. Guilds. As I suggested last night it would be nice if guilds had a "Tab for information", notification option for guild events, and a place for rules. Also Custom ranks as Stephen Teague mentioned in said thread would also be great since most guilds have other ranks in the discord then in the game. An Audit Log to see whom left or whom joined when away also whom was booted would be nice. I think guilds need some love! (Yes co gm was added awhile back but they haven't been touched since)
3. Badges/trophies (which ever you'd like to call it) I suggested this awhile back, most games these days have a system like this such as Wizard101, Call of Duty, WOW, etc... Something like "Kill Jimmy Legs 100 times" "Loot all the Cursed Famed" etc.. Currently the only Badges we have are for SvS and PvP..
4. As most people have been saying and I have been saying for awhile now, since there is constantly new clothing and weapons add a spot or something for more inventory.
5. Friend lists need to be raised kinda tired of removing people to add new people (currently at 150) In POTCO you had the option of adding people as a player friend or pirate friend or both. Total was something like 350 if you only added them as 1 or the other. Not saying it should be 350 I think just a boost too 200 would be nice.
6. Cuba this island could be much more than it is. Considered to be a main island which all it has is a clothing shop, tattoo shop, shipwright, potions, tavern, jail, and Tia Dalma. Think an expansion of this island in the future would be cool.
7. Id like to see Navy and EITC Brigs added at some point kinda always bugged me how they were never added when release to us pirates in POTCO. Yes I get they were added later on but that doesnt mean there shouldnt be enemy type brigs out there..
8. So as long as I can remember the chest system in the game was always 1 "skull" rating for pouch, 2 "skull" rating for chest, and 3 "skull" rating for Skulls. What if there was a chest with a 4 "skull" which would only drop famed/legends and a 5 "skull" that would only drop legends?
9. So awhile back we were doing a Tortuga Invasion and we encountered a mod using something that appeared to be an Ax. I hink it would be nice to have a new weapon category of Ax added to the game. Of course add #4 before you add this option..
10. Kingshead Jail! Make this functional!!
11. Tattoos - back, leg, and possibly hand tattos should be added at some point.
12. As you do for Christmas and Saint Patricks day releasing the "Bright Green hair" why no have a "Bright Red hair" for Christmas and possibly Independence day (thinking of another holiday that "Red" is related to..)
13. So in many guilds that im in or have been in there is a rule stating "Ask permission to teleport" Its there for courteous reasons. In a few other games Ive played there is a spot in the settings area where you have perms to turn this option off.. Would be nice to have this added..
14. Is it possible to add a feature that when doing mat runs or skull runs you can communicate with the captain of the ships in the area. Similar to the SVS chat??
This is all I can think of at the current moment maybe more down the road..